my name is red-ÎÒµÄÃû×ֽкì-µÚ85ÕÂ
°´¼üÅÌÉÏ·½Ïò¼ü ¡û »ò ¡ú ¿É¿ìËÙÉÏÏ·ҳ£¬°´¼üÅÌÉ쵀 Enter ¼ü¿É»Øµ½±¾ÊéĿ¼ҳ£¬°´¼üÅÌÉÏ·½Ïò¼ü ¡ü ¿É»Øµ½±¾Ò³¶¥²¿£¡
¡ª¡ª¡ª¡ªÎ´ÔĶÁÍꣿ¼ÓÈëÊéÇ©ÒѱãÏ´μÌÐøÔĶÁ£¡
picture¡¡of¡¡a¡¡horse£¿¡±¡¡
¡°I¡¡once¡¡saw¡¡a¡¡winged¡¡horse¡¡in¡¡an¡¡enchanting¡¡book¡¡that¡¡a¡¡great¡¡teacher£»¡¡a¡¡
scholar¡¡of¡¡scholars£»¡¡had¡¡presented¡¡to¡¡my¡¡late¡¡hoja¡£¡±¡¡
I¡¡didn¡¯t¡¡know¡¡whether¡¡I¡¡should¡¡push¡¡the¡¡head¡¡of¡¡this¡¡clown¡¡into¡¡his¡¡soup£»¡¡
who£»¡¡along¡¡with¡¡his¡¡teacher£»¡¡had¡¡taken¡¡Strange¡¡Creatures¡¡seriously£»¡¡and¡¡drown¡¡
him¡¡or¡¡leave¡¡him¡¡to¡¡describe¡¡in¡¡glowing¡¡terms¡¡the¡¡only¡¡horse¡¡picture¡¡he¡¯d¡¡ever¡¡
seen¡¡in¡¡his¡¡life¡ªin¡¡who¡¡knows¡¡how¡¡poor¡¡a¡¡manuscript¡¡copy¡£¡¡I¡¡came¡¡up¡¡with¡¡a¡¡
third¡¡¡¡alternative£»¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡was¡¡¡¡to¡¡¡¡drop¡¡¡¡my¡¡¡¡spoon¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡quit¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡shop¡£¡¡¡¡After¡¡
walking¡¡for¡¡a¡¡long¡¡while¡¡I¡¡entered¡¡the¡¡abandoned¡¡dervish¡¡lodge£»¡¡where¡¡I¡¡was¡¡
overe¡¡with¡¡a¡¡sense¡¡of¡¡peace¡£¡¡I¡¡tidied¡¡up¡¡and¡¡without¡¡doing¡¡anything¡¡else£»¡¡I¡¡
listened¡¡to¡¡the¡¡silence¡£¡¡
307¡¡
¡¡
Later£»¡¡I¡¡removed¡¡the¡¡mirror¡¡from¡¡where¡¡I¡¡kept¡¡it¡¡hidden¡¡and¡¡set¡¡it¡¡upon¡¡the¡¡
low¡¡worktable¡£¡¡Next£»¡¡I¡¡placed¡¡the¡¡two¡page¡¡illustration¡¡and¡¡the¡¡drawing¡¡board¡¡
on¡¡¡¡my¡¡¡¡lap¡£¡¡¡¡When¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡could¡¡¡¡see¡¡¡¡my¡¡¡¡face¡¡¡¡in¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡mirror¡¡¡¡from¡¡¡¡where¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡sat£»¡¡¡¡I¡¡
attempted¡¡to¡¡draw¡¡my¡¡portrait¡¡in¡¡charcoal¡£¡¡I¡¡drew¡¡for¡¡a¡¡long¡¡time£»¡¡patiently¡£¡¡
Much¡¡later£»¡¡when¡¡I¡¡saw¡¡that¡¡once¡¡again¡¡the¡¡face¡¡on¡¡the¡¡page¡¡didn¡¯t¡¡resemble¡¡
my¡¡¡¡face¡¡¡¡in¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡mirror£»¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡was¡¡¡¡filled¡¡¡¡with¡¡¡¡such¡¡¡¡misery¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡tears¡¡¡¡welled¡¡¡¡in¡¡¡¡my¡¡
eyes¡£¡¡How¡¡did¡¡the¡¡Veian¡¡painters¡¡that¡¡Enishte¡¡described¡¡with¡¡such¡¡flourish¡¡
do¡¡it£¿¡¡I¡¡then¡¡imagined¡¡myself¡¡to¡¡be¡¡one¡¡of¡¡them£»¡¡thinking¡¡that¡¡if¡¡I¡¡illustrated¡¡in¡¡
that¡¡state¡¡of¡¡mind£»¡¡I¡¡could¡¡perhaps¡¡make¡¡a¡¡convincing¡¡self¡portrait¡£¡¡
Later¡¡still£»¡¡I¡¡cursed¡¡the¡¡European¡¡painters¡¡and¡¡Enishte¡¡both£»¡¡erased¡¡what¡¡I¡¯d¡¡
done¡¡and¡¡began¡¡looking¡¡into¡¡the¡¡mirror¡¡anew¡¡to¡¡begin¡¡another¡¡drawing¡£¡¡
Ultimately£»¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡found¡¡¡¡myself¡¡¡¡wandering¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡streets¡¡¡¡again£»¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡then£»¡¡¡¡here£»¡¡¡¡at¡¡
this¡¡despicable¡¡coffeehouse¡£¡¡I¡¡wasn¡¯t¡¡even¡¡sure¡¡how¡¡I¡¡happened¡¡to¡¡e¡¡here¡£¡¡
As¡¡I¡¡entered£»¡¡I¡¡felt¡¡such¡¡embarrassment¡¡about¡¡mingling¡¡with¡¡these¡¡miserable¡¡
miniaturists¡¡and¡¡calligraphers¡¡that¡¡sweat¡¡accumulated¡¡on¡¡my¡¡forehead¡£¡¡
I¡¡¡¡sensed¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡they¡¡¡¡were¡¡¡¡watching¡¡¡¡me£»¡¡¡¡alerting¡¡¡¡each¡¡¡¡other¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡my¡¡¡¡presence¡¡
with¡¡their¡¡elbows£»¡¡and¡¡laughing¡ªall¡¡right£»¡¡I¡¡could¡¡plainly¡¡see¡¡them¡¡doing¡¡it¡£¡¡I¡¡
seated¡¡myself¡¡in¡¡the¡¡corner£»¡¡trying¡¡to¡¡behave¡¡naturally¡£¡¡At¡¡the¡¡same¡¡time¡¡my¡¡
eyes¡¡sought¡¡the¡¡other¡¡masters£»¡¡my¡¡dear¡¡brethren¡¡with¡¡whom£»¡¡at¡¡one¡¡time£»¡¡I¡¯d¡¡
served¡¡¡¡as¡¡¡¡Master¡¡¡¡Osman¡¯s¡¡¡¡apprentice¡£¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡was¡¡¡¡certain¡¡¡¡each¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡them¡¡¡¡was¡¡¡¡also¡¡
asked¡¡¡¡to¡¡¡¡draw¡¡¡¡a¡¡¡¡horse¡¡¡¡this¡¡¡¡evening¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡they¡¯d¡¡¡¡each¡¡¡¡expended¡¡¡¡great¡¡
desperate¡¡efforts£»¡¡taking¡¡the¡¡contest¡¡arranged¡¡by¡¡these¡¡idiots¡¡quite¡¡seriously¡£¡¡
The¡¡¡¡storyteller¡¡¡¡effendi¡¡¡¡hadn¡¯t¡¡¡¡yet¡¡¡¡begun¡¡¡¡his¡¡¡¡performance¡£¡¡¡¡The¡¡¡¡picture¡¡
hadn¡¯t¡¡even¡¡been¡¡hung¡¡up¡¡yet¡£¡¡I¡¡was¡¡forced¡¡to¡¡socialize¡¡with¡¡the¡¡coffeehouse¡¡
crowd¡£¡¡
So¡¡¡¡be¡¡¡¡it¡¡¡¡then£»¡¡¡¡let¡¡¡¡me¡¡¡¡be¡¡¡¡frank¡¡¡¡with¡¡¡¡you£º¡¡¡¡Like¡¡¡¡everyone¡¡¡¡else¡¡¡¡I£»¡¡¡¡too£»¡¡¡¡made¡¡
jokes£»¡¡¡¡told¡¡¡¡indecent¡¡¡¡stories£»¡¡¡¡kissed¡¡¡¡my¡¡¡¡panions¡¡¡¡on¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡cheeks¡¡¡¡with¡¡
exaggerated¡¡¡¡gestures£»¡¡¡¡spoke¡¡¡¡in¡¡¡¡double¡¡¡¡entendres£»¡¡¡¡innuendos¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡puns£»¡¡¡¡asked¡¡
how¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡young¡¡¡¡assistant¡¡¡¡masters¡¡¡¡were¡¡¡¡doing£»¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡like¡¡¡¡everybody¡¡¡¡else£»¡¡
mercilessly¡¡needled¡¡our¡¡mon¡¡enemies£»¡¡and¡¡after¡¡I¡¡really¡¡warmed¡¡up£»¡¡I¡¡went¡¡
so¡¡far¡¡as¡¡to¡¡roughhouse¡¡and¡¡kiss¡¡men¡¡on¡¡the¡¡neck¡£¡¡Yet£»¡¡knowing¡¡that¡¡a¡¡part¡¡of¡¡
my¡¡¡¡soul¡¡¡¡remained¡¡¡¡mercilessly¡¡¡¡silent¡¡¡¡when¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡involved¡¡¡¡myself¡¡¡¡in¡¡¡¡such¡¡¡¡behavior¡¡
caused¡¡me¡¡unbearable¡¡torment¡£¡¡
Noheless£»¡¡before¡¡long£»¡¡I¡¡not¡¡only¡¡succeeded¡¡in¡¡using¡¡figurative¡¡language¡¡
to¡¡pare¡¡my¡¡own¡¡cock£»¡¡and¡¡those¡¡of¡¡others¡¡that¡¡were¡¡much¡talked¡¡about£»¡¡to¡¡
brushes£»¡¡¡¡reeds£»¡¡¡¡coffeehouse¡¡¡¡pillars£»¡¡¡¡flutes£»¡¡¡¡newel¡¡¡¡posts£»¡¡¡¡door¡¡¡¡knockers£»¡¡¡¡leeks£»¡¡
minarets£»¡¡lady¡¡fingers¡¡in¡¡heavy¡¡syrup£»¡¡pine¡¡trees£»¡¡and¡¡twice£»¡¡to¡¡the¡¡world¡¡itself£»¡¡
308¡¡
¡¡
I¡¡was¡¡equally¡¡successful¡¡in¡¡paring¡¡the¡¡asses¡¡of¡¡much¡discussed¡¡pretty¡¡boys¡¡
to¡¡¡¡oranges£»¡¡¡¡figs£»¡¡¡¡small¡¡¡¡haycocklike¡¡¡¡pastries£»¡¡¡¡pillows¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡also¡¡¡¡to¡¡¡¡tiny¡¡¡¡anthills¡£¡¡
Meanwhile£»¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡most¡¡¡¡conceited¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡calligraphers¡¡¡¡my¡¡¡¡age¡¡¡¡was¡¡¡¡only¡¡¡¡able¡¡¡¡to¡¡
pare¡¡his¡¡oateurishly¡¡and¡¡without¡¡any¡¡self¡confidence¡¡I¡¡
might¡¡¡¡add¡ªto¡¡¡¡a¡¡¡¡ship¡¯s¡¡¡¡mast¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡a¡¡¡¡porter¡¯s¡¡¡¡pole¡£¡¡¡¡Furthermore£»¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡made¡¡
allusions¡¡¡¡to¡¡¡¡old¡¡¡¡miniaturists¡¯¡¡¡¡dicks¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡would¡¡¡¡no¡¡¡¡longer¡¡¡¡rise£»¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡cherry¡
colored¡¡¡¡lips¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡new¡¡¡¡apprentices£»¡¡¡¡master¡¡¡¡calligraphers¡¡¡¡who¡¡¡¡hoarded¡¡¡¡their¡¡
money¡¡£¨as¡¡did¡¡I£©¡¡in¡¡a¡¡certain¡¡place¡¡£¨¡°the¡¡most¡¡disgusting¡¡nook¡±£©£»¡¡how¡¡perhaps¡¡
opium¡¡had¡¡been¡¡put¡¡into¡¡the¡¡wine¡¡I¡¡was¡¡drinking¡¡instead¡¡of¡¡rose¡¡petals£»¡¡the¡¡
last¡¡¡¡great¡¡¡¡masters¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡Tabriz¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡Shiraz£»¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡mixing¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡coffee¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡wine¡¡¡¡in¡¡
Aleppo£»¡¡and¡¡the¡¡calligraphers¡¡and¡¡beautiful¡¡boys¡¡to¡¡be¡¡found¡¡there¡£¡¡
At¡¡times¡¡it¡¡seemed¡¡that¡¡one¡¡of¡¡the¡¡two¡¡spirits¡¡within¡¡me¡¡had£»¡¡in¡¡the¡¡end£»¡¡
emerged¡¡¡¡victorious£»¡¡¡¡leaving¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡other¡¡¡¡behind£»¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡I¡¯d¡¡¡¡finally¡¡¡¡forgotten¡¡
that¡¡¡¡silent¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡loveless¡¡¡¡aspect¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡myself¡£¡¡¡¡At¡¡¡¡these¡¡¡¡times¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡remembered¡¡¡¡the¡¡
holiday¡¡¡¡celebrations¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡my¡¡¡¡childhood¡¡¡¡during¡¡¡¡which¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡was¡¡¡¡able¡¡¡¡to¡¡¡¡be¡¡¡¡myself¡¡
along¡¡with¡¡my¡¡kith¡¡and¡¡kin¡£¡¡Despite¡¡all¡¡these¡¡jokes£»¡¡kisses¡¡and¡¡embraces£»¡¡there¡¡
was¡¡still¡¡a¡¡silence¡¡within¡¡me¡¡that¡¡left¡¡me¡¡suffering¡¡and¡¡isolated¡¡in¡¡the¡¡heart¡¡of¡¡
the¡¡crowd¡£¡¡
Who¡¡¡¡had¡¡¡¡endowed¡¡¡¡me¡¡¡¡with¡¡¡¡this¡¡¡¡silent¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡merciless¡¡¡¡spirit¡ªit¡¡¡¡was¡¡¡¡not¡¡¡¡a¡¡
spirit¡¡but¡¡a¡¡jinn¡ªwhich¡¡always¡¡chided¡¡me¡¡and¡¡cut¡¡me¡¡off¡¡from¡¡others£¿¡¡Satan£¿¡¡
But¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡silence¡¡¡¡within¡¡¡¡me¡¡¡¡was¡¡¡¡eased£»¡¡¡¡not¡¡¡¡by¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡crass¡¡¡¡mischief¡¡¡¡instigated¡¡¡¡by¡¡
Satan£»¡¡¡¡on¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡contrary£»¡¡¡¡by¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡most¡¡¡¡pure¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡simple¡¡¡¡stories¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡drove¡¡¡¡into¡¡
one¡¯s¡¡¡¡soul¡£¡¡¡¡Under¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡influence¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡wine£»¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡told¡¡¡¡two¡¡¡¡stories£»¡¡¡¡hoping¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡this¡¡
would¡¡¡¡grant¡¡¡¡me¡¡¡¡peace¡£¡¡¡¡A¡¡¡¡tall£»¡¡¡¡pale£»¡¡¡¡yet¡¡¡¡pinkish¡plected¡¡¡¡calligrapher¡¯s¡¡
apprentice¡¡focused¡¡his¡¡green¡¡eyes¡¡onto¡¡mine¡¡and¡¡was¡¡listening¡¡to¡¡me¡¡with¡¡rapt¡¡
attention¡£¡¡
¡¡
Two¡¡Stories¡¡on¡¡Blindness¡¡and¡¡Style¡¡
the¡¡Miniaturist¡¡Told¡¡to¡¡Ease¡¡the¡¡Loneliness¡¡in¡¡His¡¡Soul¡¡
¡¡
ALIF¡¡
Contrary¡¡to¡¡what¡¡is¡¡assumed£»¡¡making¡¡drawings¡¡of¡¡horses¡¡by¡¡looking¡¡at¡¡actual¡¡
horses¡¡wasn¡¯t¡¡a¡¡discovery¡¡of¡¡European¡¡masters¡£¡¡The¡¡original¡¡idea¡¡belonged¡¡to¡¡
the¡¡¡¡great¡¡¡¡master¡¡¡¡Jemalettin¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡Kazvin¡£¡¡¡¡After¡¡¡¡Tall¡¡¡¡Hasan£»¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡Khan¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡the¡¡
Whitesheep£»¡¡conquered¡¡Kazvin£»¡¡the¡¡old¡¡master¡¡Jemalettin¡¡was¡¡not¡¡content¡¡to¡¡
simply¡¡join¡¡the¡¡book¡arts¡¡workshop¡¡of¡¡the¡¡victorious¡¡khan£»¡¡instead¡¡he¡¡headed¡¡
out¡¡on¡¡campaign¡¡with¡¡him£»¡¡claiming¡¡that¡¡he¡¡wanted¡¡to¡¡embellish¡¡the¡¡khan¡¯s¡¡
309¡¡
¡¡
History¡¡with¡¡scenes¡¡of¡¡war¡¡he¡¯d¡¡witnessed¡¡himself¡£¡¡So¡¡this¡¡great¡¡master£»¡¡who¡¡
for¡¡¡¡sixty¡two¡¡¡¡years¡¡¡¡had¡¡¡¡made¡¡¡¡pictures¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡horses£»¡¡¡¡cavalry¡¡¡¡charges¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡battles¡¡
without¡¡ever¡¡having¡¡seen¡¡a¡¡battle£»¡¡went¡¡to¡¡war¡¡for¡¡the¡¡first¡¡time¡£¡¡But¡¡before¡¡he¡¡
could¡¡even¡¡see¡¡the¡¡thunderous¡¡and¡¡violent¡¡clash¡¡of¡¡sweating¡¡horses£»¡¡he¡¡lost¡¡his¡¡
hands¡¡and¡¡his¡¡eyesight¡¡to¡¡enemy¡¡cannon¡fire¡£¡¡The¡¡old¡¡master£»¡¡like¡¡all¡¡genuine¡¡
virtuosos£»¡¡¡¡had¡¡¡¡in¡¡¡¡any¡¡¡¡case¡¡¡¡been¡¡¡¡awaiting¡¡¡¡blindness¡¡¡¡as¡¡¡¡though¡¡¡¡it¡¡¡¡were¡¡¡¡Allah¡¯s¡¡
blessing£»¡¡and¡¡neither¡¡did¡¡he¡¡treat¡¡the¡¡loss¡¡of¡¡his¡¡hands¡¡as¡¡a¡¡great¡¡deficiency¡£¡¡He¡¡
maintained¡¡that¡¡the¡¡memory¡¡of¡¡a¡¡miniaturist¡¡was¡¡located¡¡not¡¡in¡¡the¡¡hand£»¡¡as¡¡
some¡¡insisted£»¡¡but¡¡in¡¡the¡¡intellect¡¡and¡¡the¡¡heart£»¡¡and¡¡furthermore£»¡¡now¡¡that¡¡he¡¡
was¡¡blind£»¡¡he¡¡declared¡¡that¡¡he¡¡could¡¡see¡¡the¡¡true¡¡pictures£»¡¡scenery¡¡and¡¡essential¡¡
and¡¡¡¡flawless¡¡¡¡horses¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡Allah¡¡¡¡manded¡¡¡¡be¡¡¡¡seen¡£¡¡¡¡To¡¡¡¡share¡¡¡¡these¡¡¡¡wonders¡¡
with¡¡¡¡lovers¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡art£»¡¡¡¡he¡¡¡¡hired¡¡¡¡a¡¡¡¡tall£»¡¡¡¡pale¡skinned£»¡¡¡¡pink¡plected£»¡¡¡¡green¡eyed¡¡
calligrapher¡¯s¡¡¡¡apprentice¡¡¡¡to¡¡¡¡whom¡¡¡¡he¡¡¡¡dictated¡¡¡¡exactly¡¡¡¡how¡¡¡¡to¡¡¡¡draw¡¡¡¡the¡¡
marvelous¡¡¡¡horses¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡appeared¡¡¡¡to¡¡¡¡him¡¡¡¡in¡¡¡¡God¡¯s¡¡¡¡divine¡¡¡¡darkness¡ªas¡¡¡¡he¡¡
would¡¯ve¡¡drawn¡¡them¡¡had¡¡he¡¡been¡¡able¡¡to¡¡hold¡¡a¡¡brush¡¡in¡¡his¡¡hands¡£¡¡After¡¡the¡¡
master¡¯s¡¡death£»¡¡his¡¡account¡¡of¡¡how¡¡to¡¡draw¡¡303¡¡horses¡¡beginning¡¡from¡¡the¡¡left¡¡
foreleg¡¡¡¡was¡¡¡¡collected¡¡¡¡by¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡handsome¡¡¡¡calligrapher¡¯s¡¡¡¡apprentice¡¡¡¡into¡¡¡¡three¡¡
volumes¡¡respectively¡¡entitled¡¡The¡¡Depiction¡¡of¡¡Horses£»¡¡The¡¡Flow¡¡of¡¡Horses¡¡and¡¡The¡¡
Love¡¡of¡¡Horses£»¡¡which¡¡were¡¡quite¡¡widely¡¡liked¡¡and¡¡sought¡¡after¡¡for¡¡a¡¡time¡¡in¡¡the¡¡
regions¡¡where¡¡the¡¡Whitesheep¡¡ruled¡£¡¡Though¡¡they¡¡appeared¡¡in¡¡a¡¡variety¡¡of¡¡new¡¡
editions¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡copies£»¡¡¡¡were¡¡¡¡memorized¡¡¡¡by¡¡¡¡illustrators£»¡¡¡¡apprentices¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡their¡¡
students¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡were¡¡¡¡used¡¡¡¡as¡¡¡¡practice¡¡¡¡books£»¡¡¡¡after¡¡¡¡Tall¡¡¡¡Hasan¡¯s¡¡¡¡Whitesheep¡¡
nation¡¡was¡¡obliterated¡¡and¡¡the¡¡Herat¡¡style¡¡of¡¡illustration¡¡overtook¡¡all¡¡of¡¡Persia£»¡¡
Jemalettin¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡his¡¡¡¡manuscripts¡¡¡¡were¡¡¡¡forgotten¡£¡¡¡¡Doubtless£»¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡logic¡¡¡¡behind¡¡
Kemalettin¡¡R£¿za¡¡of¡¡Herat¡¯s¡¡violent¡¡criticism¡¡of¡¡these¡¡three¡¡volumes¡¡in¡¡his¡¡book¡¡
The¡¡Blindman¡¯s¡¡Horses£»¡¡and¡¡his¡¡conclusion¡¡that¡¡they¡¡ought¡¡to¡¡be¡¡burned£»¡¡had¡¡
figured¡¡in¡¡this¡¡turn¡¡of¡¡events¡£¡¡Kemalettin¡¡R£¿za¡¡claimed¡¡that¡¡none¡¡of¡¡the¡¡horses¡¡
described¡¡¡¡by¡¡¡¡Jemalettin¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡Kazvin¡¡¡¡in¡¡¡¡his¡¡¡¡three¡¡¡¡volumes¡¡¡¡could¡¡¡¡be¡¡¡¡a¡¡¡¡horse¡¡¡¡of¡¡
God¡¯s¡¡vision¡ªbecause¡¡none¡¡of¡¡them¡¡were¡¡¡°immaculate£»¡±¡¡since¡¡the¡¡old¡¡master¡¡
had¡¡¡¡described¡¡¡¡them¡¡¡¡after¡¡¡¡he¡¯d¡¡¡¡witnessed¡¡¡¡an¡¡¡¡actual¡¡¡¡battle¡¡¡¡scene£»¡¡¡¡no¡¡¡¡matter¡¡
how¡¡¡¡briefly¡£¡¡¡¡Since¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡treasures¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡Tall¡¡¡¡Hasan¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡Whitesheep¡¡¡¡had¡¡¡¡been¡¡
plundered¡¡¡¡by¡¡¡¡Sultan¡¡¡¡Mehmet¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡Conqueror¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡brought¡¡¡¡to¡¡¡¡Istanbul£»¡¡¡¡it¡¡
should¡¡¡¡e¡¡¡¡as¡¡¡¡no¡¡¡¡surprise¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡occasionally¡¡¡¡certain¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡these¡¡¡¡303¡¡¡¡stories¡¡
appear¡¡in¡¡other¡¡manuscripts¡¡in¡¡Istanbul¡¡and¡¡even¡¡that¡¡some¡¡horses¡¡are¡¡drawn¡¡
as¡¡instructed¡¡therein¡£¡¡
¡¡
¡¡¡¡¡¡
310¡¡
¡¡
LAM¡¡
In¡¡¡¡Herat¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡Shiraz£»¡¡¡¡when¡¡¡¡a¡¡¡¡master¡¡¡¡miniaturist¡¡¡¡nearing¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡end¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡his¡¡¡¡days¡¡
went¡¡blind¡¡from¡¡a¡¡lifetime¡¡of¡¡excessive¡¡labor£»¡¡it¡¡woul